ICFs (Solid Mass Walls) vs Wood Walls (Cavity Walls)
A cavity wall is an exterior wall built in two separate layers, called wythes, with a continuous air gap, or cavity, between them. In traditional construction, the inner wythe carries the structural load (typically wood or steel framing) while the outer wythe acts as a weather-resistant veneer (brick, stone, or siding), tied together with metal wall ties. The cavity itself is usually a few inches wide and is often filled with insulation, while still leaving room for drainage and ventilation that helps manage moisture.
Most homes built with conventional 2×6 wood framing are, in effect, a type of cavity wall system. The tradeoff is that the wall’s strength and insulation depend on multiple separate components working together, which is the main point of comparison with a solid mass wall like an ICF, where the structure, insulation, and air/moisture barrier are combined into one continuous concrete wall.
Let us look at construction from the end user point of view, the homeowner or home buyer. There are many reasons most people consider before building a home. Let us assume our end user has property to build on and a rough idea how his house plan is laid out. We will go one step further and say our end user has a house plan already which was purchased online and drawn with wood 2×6 walls.
Consideration | Cavity Wall (Wood) | Solid Mass Wall (ICF) |
|---|---|---|
Blueprint Design, Layout | In this scenario our plans were purchased online. | Using the same blueprints you would simply maintain inside dimensions. The added thickness of wall would be added to the outside. May require a cross-section of ICF wall with re-enforcement detail |
Protection: Natural or man-made Disasters. Tornado, Hurricane, Seismic, Flood, Fire, War etc. | Billions of dollars in losses due to the destruction of conventionally built structures due to natural disasters. Including black mold from water damage. | Can be designed to withstand 200 mph plus winds. 3 to 4-hour fire rated walls. Does not support mold or mildew. |
Green Build LEED point contributions | Average lifespan; 80 years. More jobsite waste added carbon footprint. Deforestation, higher energy costs, higher labor costs. | Average lifespan; 200 + years. Less waste, reduced landfill, lower energy costs, reduced carbon footprint, indoor air quality, higher occupant satisfaction, high safety level |
Timeline: Start to finish time frame, The speed of construction | Shortened construction season in cold weather climates, higher installation cost, and longer build time. | The speed of construction, framing, insulating |
Construction Cost: Actual construction vs. Long-term savings | Overall cost of conventional framing is generally less than ICF saving an average of 3%, but, additional operating and maintenance cost is substantially more over the long term. | Cost of construction will vary from region to region but we will use 3% as our added cost to build. In the long term, the breakeven point is usually 5 years, saving you thousands of dollars over the life of your home. |
Heating & Cooling, Sizing HVAC, Air quality | More upfront cost for heating and cooling units and higher operating costs | Downsize size of heating and cooling units with lower operating costs. |
Sound | Average sound transmission (STC) rating of 36-38 | STC rating of 54+ quiet secure feeling |
Sustainability: The lifespan of Structure | 80-year average. More landfill | 200 Plus years possibly doubling or tripling that figure. Lower maintenance |
This actually is how many of us start when dreaming of that special home. We look at lots of layouts and try to find that perfect plan that just seems to fit our families wants and needs. This is the scenario we will use for our comparison. We will cover homebuyers who prefer to look for homes that have already been built, apartment buildings and such in the contractor and builder sections. This section is about the end-user that wants to be a part of the construction process whether it is in the design stage, choosing the right builder, or getting your hands dirty and helping on all or a portion of the build. Now, back to our scenario:
For anyone who is looking to design, market, build or own a new home and wants to use the best possible system for building a strong, energy-efficient, safe, healthy home. Insulated concrete form construction is the solution.
If you’re serious about wanting the home of the future now and you want to know a stronger, safer, quieter and more energy efficient way to do it, then you need to consider building a better home with insulating concrete forms.
Learn from 200+ expert videos!
Let Us Help
Contact BuildBlock today and let our staff answer your questions and help make your project a success.
Fields marked with an * are required.
By submitting this form, you agree to our Privacy Policy. We use your information to answer your request and may email you about BuildBlock products. You can unsubscribe at any time.